We know that passing off the text generated by Chat GPT or Gemini for human writing is cheating, but can it also cause plagiarism? It turns out, it can; this phenomenon is called AI plagiarism or “AIgiarism” and is another reason for checking any piece of content for AI traces and similarities.

This is how a number of tools emerged — AI-text Detectors or AI plagiarism checkers that recognize AI writing. They help prevent violations of academic integrity and AI plagiarism or AIgiarism when AI-generated texts are passed off as human-written. How accurate can such checkers be? Let’s figure it out.

AI-text Detectors and AI plagiarism checkers: is there a difference?

If the text is not written by you but taken from another source, it should be cited regardless of its human-authored or AI origin. Otherwise, it will be considered plagiarism. So, if we use AI text, it should be labeled accordingly. However, while the integrity policies of educational institutions, media sites, and publishing houses are being updated, some unscrupulous authors attempt to pass off AI-generated text as their own, thus promoting AI plagiarism. Furthermore, AI chatbots themselves may not generate original content and could potentially contain instances of plagiarism.

However, it is important to distinguish between “AI plagiarism checkers” — detectors that recognize AI text to avoid AI plagiarism; and “AI plagiarism checkers” — plagiarism checking tools that use AI capabilities to search for similarities between various human-written texts.

This article will considerAI detectors.

How much plagiarism is allowed?

Uniqueness and integrity above all. The policies of various institutions, mass media outlets, publishing houses, and others determine the allowed level of similarity in texts through different approaches. However, on average, it typically falls within 15 percent or less. Similarly, the policies regarding the use of AI are being updated.

Some organizations have established in their policies which results are passable (for example, Human-written and Likely human-written); and also, the persantage of AI sentences permissible in the texts.

are ai checkers accurate

How accurate are AI plagiarism checkers?

Accuracy is one of the most important criteria to consider when choosing an AI Detector. The best solution, such as AI Plagiarism Checker: Trace GPT, have an accuracy of over 97% which minimizes false positive and false negative results when sentences are falsely identified as written by AI (false positive) or not written by AI (false negative). Unfortunately, not all tools can provide sufficiently accurate and reliable results. It’s necessary to pay attention to:

  • Was the AI Detector trained on a sufficient number of data sets?
  • Does the tool recognize the latest models of AI generators?
  • Does AI Detector continue to develop its algorithms, along with the development of AI writing?

What is AI plagiarism

AI plagiarism is a form of plagiarism that emerges when the text has been generated by a chatbot. It happens, that when scanning AI-generated paper for plagiarism, the checker detects a high percentage of copied text.

The thing is that AI tools are incapable of creating content from scratch. They compile and generate texts and images based on the enormous amount of data they have been trained at, sometimes accidentally repeating certain pieces, which can be detected by a plagiarism scanner.

But is it even allowed to use AI technologies in education and at work? It depends. While it is obviously unethical and dishonest to generate essays and other writing tasks with AI, there are ecological and constructive ways to include new technologies into work and study routines.

Can AI generate original content? Technically AI-produced text can be recognized as an original, as the instruments evolve, and chatbots improve their ability to generate naturally-sounding and novel-seeming pieces. However, the texts still can not be considered truly original, as their content is based on someone’s work–remember, we said that AI has been trained on a vast amount of data? When the output does not attribute the sources, it makes any AI-generated content plagiarism by definition. Besides, AI-produced text is not always accurate, as it doesn’t fact-check the information it uses. Modern AI models provide links to the sources they used. However, it is crucial to stay attentive as chatbots still occasionally make mistakes and refer to made up or irrelevant resources.

So, does using AI content always entail plagiarism problems? Not necessarily. However, using AI-generated text is a form of academic cheating by itself. It is also not the best idea for content specialists, as search engines rank AI-produced content lower, impacting the website’s visibility. Hence, even if the plagiarism detector doesn’t recognize any problems, it is better to use AI as an advisor, but never as a text author.

How to check for AI writing

The best way to stay on the safe side is to check any content for traces of AI writing. This will highlight the potentially problematic parts and help to prevent AI misuse and plagiarism-caused consequences.

AI text detector is a tool that is trained to distinguish between AI-generated and human-written text based on the traits characteristic of machine and human writing. One of them is predictability, as AI tends to use the most likely applicable constructions, while human writing creativity is limitless. AI checking tool will never tell you with 100% certainty that the text was AI or human-produced, but can be used as a compass to eliminate concerns or, on the contrary, draw your attention to probable issues.

So, the simple steps to be on the safe side when you work with content are:

  • Never use AI to produce the final text; implement chatbots for brainstorming and creativity boost, but write by yourself.
  • Use a plagiarism checker to guarantee that your content is original and avoid AI plagiarism and accidental copying.
  • Use an AI detector to ensure your text sounds natural, is recognized as authentic; and to avoid potential AI-caused plagiarism accusations.
  • Always cite your sources, make an original contribution to the content you create, and fact-check and proofread the final result. If you use AI for getting information, you can cite it too!

Why can’t we do without an AI Detector tool in the future?

Artificial intelligence writes more and more human-like. However, AI will always be a machine. And its negligent use can lead to significant losses in business:

  • AI texts may contain inaccuracies, misleading information, produce biased content, and even plagiarism;
  • AI texts cannot surprise with absolute novelty; all information is available on the Internet and was known before;
  • AI-chat bots do not know how to write originally, between the lines, and with soul. All his texts have a similar formulaic style.

AI Detector allows you to warn and prevent attempts to use the AI chatbots where it is unacceptable.

The highest accuracy (95-99%) is observed in detectors that use the author’s recognition models and provide a reliable verdict. PlagiarismCheck.org AI detector with percentage guarantees 97% accuracy and continues to grow. Thanks to the multi-level system of determining the analysis results,  this solution is trusted by students and educators wordlwide.

AI Detection FAQ

How does AI-detector distinguish between machine and human writing?

The analysis is based on a complex of metrics, the crucial among which is the creativity/predictability ratio.

ChatGPT, Google Bard, and other content generators tend to be more predictable than humans. It means they will most probably choose the specific wording above other variants.

So, the algorithm sets a certain threshold, and the metrics below it are considered to show predictability unlikely for human writing. At the same time, texts creative enough to be composed by humans apply above the threshold. There come the results: “most likely AI-generated”/”most likely written by a human”.

Is the AI detector always accurate?

No AI detector gives you a definite answer of “yes” or “no”, or 100% accuracy.

In the check report, the high percentage shows that a certain amount of text matches what the detector knows about how the AI-generated texts look. However, it is all about the probability. AI detectors can prompt to pay attention to a specific paper or student, but the final verdict is always yours.

Furthermore, humans sometimes write like AI, and AI sometimes writes like humans. So, the detector can occasionally recognize the human-written text as AI and vice versa. We at PlagiarismCheck.org constantly improve the tool and strive for maximum accuracy – currently, we manage to detect AI with 97% correctness.

What should you do with AI detection results?

Consider an AI detector a compass. If the tool says the paper is likely to be composed by the AI, it definitely requires your closer attention.

Look at the parts of the text highlighted as probably AI-generated. If it applies to separate sentences, most likely there is nothing to worry about, as students are hardly interested in generating random sentences. However, if AI is traced in whole paragraphs, you should consider analyzing the paper and talking to the student.

How can you check the student if the detector says the paper is likely to be AI-generated?

First, let us gently remind you that the “Likely generated by AI” result is not the final verdict. So, the aim of an additional interview with a student is a clarification, not an accusation.

Here are some ideas to help you sort it out.

  1. Pay attention to the student’s story and reputation – have they ever been noticed for academic cheating before?
  2. Address your students some questions based on the paper, focusing on the parts highlighted by the AI detector. This way, you will test their understanding of the material and check whether the writing is based on analysis and reflection or ChatGPT’s help.
  3. Request your student to present any drafts and notes to see how the paper was crafted, and ask about the sources they used and the logic behind the writing process. You can implement writing tracking tools like Integrito to your workflow to make the process more transparent.
  4. Verify authorship with the Fingerprint tool. If you have the original papers of the student, Fingerprint can analyze their style, compare the new papers to it, and show if the writing becomes uncharacteristic for the student.
  5. Trust your guts. Your experience of teaching and interacting with students can help to understand whether the person is honest with you in a particular situation.